A Return to Subjectivity

John F. Caddy (SMN)

Trafford, 2006, 325 pp., – ISBN 141208366

Reviewed by: David Lorimer

 

Science Meets Shamanism

John Caddy is a marine biologist who has undertaken his own personal odyssey from science to spirit, which he describes in this book. His two central preoccupations are shamanism and the pursuit of vital energy as ways of directly experiencing spirituality and altered states of consciousness. The view he describes at the end of the book is essentially shamanic in postulating ‘that a spiritual essence permeates the world, and links us as entities of vital energy to each other, but also to all the other plants and animals on the planet’ in ‘Gaia’s Field’. He concludes that ‘subtle energy is omnipresent in this world, and the space around us is full of subtle energy, chi, prana, or whatever you choose to call it. At times, his experiences are difficult to reconcile with his scientific training, but, as he observes, since his experiences are direct, they are not easy to discard as an illusion. He can now switch on the capacity to see subtle energy as required, but observes that ‘acquiring a sixth sense requires reconditioning the mind through non ordinary experiences.’

            This characterises the tension between subjective and objective approaches to reality, between presuppositions and experience, between openness and skepticism, between indigenous and Western perspectives, themes that are central concerns of the Network. John relates his own procedures for psychic investigations, using both imagination and scientific observation, along with a rigorous but open-minded and integrative type of evaluation. He also explores questions of validity and alternative explanations and describes many personal experiences and courses attended. He arrives at the position that we all have the capacity to perceive vital energy directly and have extraordinary experiences. For John, this means that it is impossible to treat the planet as an inanimate object, which he thinks means accepting ‘some enlightened shamanistic perspectives into our belief system.’

            At the end of the book, John sets out in the main components of his theory of nearly everything (TONE) in a chart consisting of fact, myths, personal observations, axioms and hypotheses. This provides a consistent account of his overall worldview, many elements of which will be familiar to readers, and builds on the contents of the book examining a vast range of topics such as barriers to perception, trance, the energy of words, visualisation, magic places, spirals and fractals, auras and chakras, seeing and hearing energy, dreaming and Guardian Angels, and memes. John’s thesis is consistent with much recent work on a participatory approach or worldview as a means of overcoming the dichotomy between subjective and objective, which I think provides a more constructive framework than simply returning to the subjective. Although the content of the book is fascinating, it does suffer from a lack of outside editing and is hard to follow since it (intentionally) jumps between theory and personal accounts, with further additional observations thrown in. There is a bibliography but no index, which would have been helpful. The book will appeal most to readers who have undertaken similar journeys, and have struggled to reconcile science and spirit in their own lives.